Core earnings strengthen as recovery dependence falls
PAT +12.8%, NII +10.8%, reported operating profit +4.2% from detailed table; core +29.4%.
Watch: WATCH; underwrite recurring return
Home / Research / Punjab National Bank
Core earnings strengthen as recovery dependence falls
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
PAT +12.8%, NII +10.8%, reported operating profit +4.2% from detailed table; core +29.4%.
Watch: WATCH; underwrite recurring return
Core ex treasury/recovery: 5,971 vs 4,614 (+29.4%). Detailed reported op profit 7,532 vs 7,227; highlight conflicts, detailed table used.
Watch: Use like-for-like detailed P&L
NII 11,601 vs 10,469; Q1 10,798. H1 22,400 +6.4%.
Watch: Track recurring interest and funding cost
Fees 1,954 vs 1,685, Q1 2,339; processing 295 vs 938 Q1.
Watch: Normalize processing fees
SAGE PRO | Institutional research | 16 November 2026 | Q2 FY27 | WATCH — conditional constructive
Original October 16 investor presentation and management call (transcript filed October 23) accepted and fully scored in Sage PRO. Original exchange filing retained. Amounts in ₹ crore unless stated. Independent statutory-to-model and current-market peer valuation reconciliation incomplete. No executable target.
Key takeaways
Management's more informative comparison is core operating profit excluding treasury and P&L written-off recovery: +29.4% YoY, 79% of reported operating profit versus 64% prior year. This shows a meaningful transition from legacy/market-sensitive income toward interest and fee earnings.
The constructive variant is that a healthier underwritten loan book, improving margins and a large domestic deposit base can support sustainable ROA around or above 1% even as recoveries diminish. The counter-hypothesis is that current low credit cost and provision movements overstate durable returns, legacy gross NPA remains higher than several peer banks, and loan growth faster than deposit growth makes margin recovery harder.
PNB's current favorable quarter is not the same as a through-cycle ROE estimate. Compare its normalized return on book, marginal funding and asset quality with SBI, Canara and BoB, avoiding headline P/E comparisons distorted by investment gains or legacy provisions.
WATCH until core income continues to replace recovery dependence and funding remains disciplined.
| Bank ₹ crore | Sep 2025 | Jun 2026 | Sep 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Global advances | 11,69,592 | 12,73,132 | 13,41,194 |
| Domestic advances | 11,17,885 | 12,03,859 | 12,57,083 |
| Overseas advances | 51,707 | 69,273 | 84,110 |
| Global deposits | 16,17,080 | 17,24,837 | 17,77,240 |
| Domestic deposits | 15,63,982 | 16,70,177 | 17,11,840 |
| Global CD ratio | 72.3% | 73.8% | 75.5% |
Key takeaways
The issuer-defined growth measure should not be recreated by adding or subtracting this one number from unmatched prior balances. IBPC changes may affect funding, risk transfer and reported loan scope; track originations and actual borrower exposure rather than headline balances.
Retail 2,96,925 (+9.1%) versus retail ex IBPC 2,71,565 (+16.3%); housing ex IBPC +14.3%, vehicles ex IBPC +29.6%. Agriculture total 2,10,451 (+14.4%) and priority-sector agriculture +18.1%; MSME 2,14,619 (+19.8%).
Domestic RAM 7,21,996 (+13.6%) represents 57.4% of domestic advances. Corporate/others 5,35,088 (+10.9%). The different retail and agricultural definitions explain why management's core product growth is higher than the headline RAM measure.
Do not combine these growth rates as if identical scope. The call cites corporate pipeline 1.58 lakh crore and H1 sanctions above 2.5 lakh crore; sanctions and pipeline are not disbursements or booked earnings.
Track drawdowns, pricing, RWA and client-level fee/deposit contribution.
Management says loans sanctioned since July 2020 total around 15.97 lakh crore, disbursed 14.09 lakh crore, outstanding 9.60 lakh crore (71.6% of total outstanding), with NPA 0.42% of disbursed amount. The denominator is cumulative disbursement, not outstanding or a lifetime expected-loss rate.
It is encouraging evidence of improved underwriting but not a direct vintage default probability. The remaining legacy exposure can still drive absolute stress and provision releases. Monitor new vintages by outstanding balance, arrears, product, origination year and realized loss.
| Bank ₹ crore | Q2 FY26 | Q1 FY27 | Q2 FY27 |
|---|---|---|---|
| NII | 10,469 | 10,798 | 11,601 |
| Fee income | 1,685 | 2,339 | 1,954 |
| Written-off recovery (P&L) | 844 | 908 | 808 |
| Treasury income | 1,769 | 1,081 | 753 |
| Other income total | 4,342 | 4,333 | 3,601 |
| Operating income | 14,811 | 15,132 | 15,202 |
| Operating expenses | 7,584 | 7,613 | 7,670 |
| Operating profit | 7,227 | 7,519 | 7,532 |
| Provisions ex tax | 643 | 541 | 97 |
| PBT | 6,584 | 6,978 | 7,435 |
| PAT | 4,904 | 5,253 | 5,532 |
Key takeaways
This matches management's stated core growth and mix. The remaining measure includes other receipts and is not a full audited alternative P&L. It nevertheless gives a stronger underlying signal than reported profit alone. Fee income +16% YoY but fell from Q1, which included 938 processing fees compared with 295 in Q2; avoid annualizing Q1. Treasury −57.4% and P&L recoveries −4.2% show the need for recurring fee/NII expansion.
Q2 expenses +1.1%, establishment −7.2% while other operating expense +15%. Cost/income 50.45% versus 51.20% prior year and 50.31% Q1. H1 NII 22,400 (+6.4%), operating profit 15,051 (+5.2%), operating expense 15,283 (−6.5%).
H1 PAT from quarter series 10,785. The cost bridge requires separation of staff expense timing and durable productivity. Provisions excluding tax fell to 97 from 643 prior year, yet NPA provision line was 817 versus negative 639.
This means other provision categories offset the NPA line materially; do not equate the net 97 with new expected loan loss. Forecast specific credit losses, noncredit provisions and reversals separately.
A 25bp annualized credit cost increase on current period-end gross advances 13,41,194 would cost about 3,353 pre-tax on an illustrative static basis; actual average denominator and provision definition differ.
Key takeaways
The funding franchise must be measured by active primary-account relationships, stable balances and cost, not number of accounts. The bank's FY27 guidance targets CASA 38%; current mix is below that level.
Global deposits +9.9%, domestic +9.5%, versus global advances +14.7%; CD 75.5% and management-reported LCR about 133%. The relatively moderate CD ratio provides headroom but is not a guarantee against high marginal deposit costs.
Management raised US$2.7bn FCNR against a US$2.5bn target, reportedly replacing high-cost bulk deposits and CDs rather than pursuing gross volume; Q&A identified roughly 70% leveraged and 30% self-funded. Do not infer net free liquidity from the gross amount.
Linked assets, guarantees, currency swaps and maturity affect economic cost. Compared with BoB's strategy of retaining more of its special funding for seasonal deployment, PNB's stated approach emphasizes replacing expensive funding; verify actual interest expense and average balance evolution rather than treating the two strategies as identical.
Domestic quarterly NIM rose 10bp sequentially to 2.74% from 2.64%; global NIM rose 8bp to 2.58% from 2.50%. H1 global NIM 2.54%; FY27 guidance 2.60–2.70%. Management expects continued improvement, not a guaranteed margin.
Global NII +10.8% Q2 exceeds the 7% FY27 growth guidance; H1 +6.4%. The timing of deposit repricing, credit deployment and benchmark-linked yields matters more than a quarter-end balance increase. Quarterly interest paid on borrowings rose from 215 to 637; deposit interest +4.9%.
A cheaper funding strategy must be tested through all funding sources, not deposit rates alone. On hypothetical ₹16 lakh crore average earning assets, a 10bp annual NIM movement changes annual NII by ₹1,600 crore pre-tax.
This is a scale illustration, not PNB's disclosed average asset denominator.
Key takeaways
The Q2 bridge: opening 35,381 + gross additions 2,395 − total reductions 3,586 = 34,190. Fresh slippages 2,233 versus 1,996 Q1 and 1,812 prior year; additions include 162 debits in existing NPA accounts. Cash recovery 1,092, upgrades 670, write-offs 1,824. These are different categories; do not call total reductions cash. Q2 total recovery 2,805 includes cash, upgrades and written-off/RI recovery of 1,043; that is not the P&L recovery line 808. Reconcile reporting definitions before modeling income.
Annualized slippage 0.77% versus 0.71% prior year, H1 0.64%. Current credit cost 0.25% within management below-0.4% guidance. PCR 97.32% including technical write-offs and 90.31% excluding them; the coverage bases differ.
SMA2 loans above ₹5 crore 1,159 (0.09% of domestic advances) versus 1,873 (0.17%) a year earlier. The early-warning improvement is constructive, but it covers a specified loan scope and does not negate rising fresh slippages.
MSME and agriculture loan expansion deserve separate monitoring.
September CRAR 17.95%, CET1 14.44%, Tier 1 15.89%, Tier 2 2.06%. Call confirms additional floating provision 125, total 2,560. Management discussed revised estimated ECL on loan book of roughly 8,000 versus earlier 9,000–10,000 and suggested recurring credit cost including its estimated effect could remain 0.25–0.30%.
These are October management estimates, not confirmed regulatory/accounting effects or incremental P&L charges. In particular, gross ECL requirement, existing buffers and actual opening-equity impact differ.
Management confidence does not establish a zero capital impact. Reconcile actual rules, stages, model assumptions, existing provisions, HTM effects and regulatory treatment before adjusting book value.
Branch expansion: management planned 250 FY27 branches, opened 162 by Q2, 119 in southern/western regions. H1 digital sanctions above 41,500 and over 95% transactions digital, per call. Digital sanction volumes are not loan disbursements, revenue or cash savings. Assess incremental deposits and customer profitability from branches, technology cost and credit quality. Digital productivity must be visible in recurring fees, cost/income and service outcomes.
Key takeaways
Choose a consistent numerator and equity base; do not apply a tangible-book ROE to total book and claim the same value. Management discussed ROE around 15–17% and ROA above 1%; these are expectations. A simplified justified price/tangible-book sensitivity is (sustainable tangible ROE−g)/(Ke−g).
| Illustrative case | Bear | Base | Bull |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sustainable tangible ROE | 12% | 15.5% | 18% |
| Global NIM assumption | 2.35% | 2.60% | 2.75% |
| Credit cost | 0.65% | 0.40% | 0.25% |
| Long-run growth | 6% | 7% | 7.5% |
| Cost of equity | 15% | 14% | 13% |
| Justified P/tangible book | 0.67× | 1.21× | 1.91× |
This model assumes steady-state clean-surplus returns and growth below cost of equity. Bear assumes new slippage and expensive funding, fading recoveries and weaker returns. Base assumes margin normalization and core income replaces declining recovery with manageable risk costs.
Bull requires strong recurring fees, stable marginal funding and low loss without reserve releases. At base, 1pp lower ROE reduces implied multiple by 0.14×; 1pp higher Ke reduces it to 1.06×. These are analyst scenarios, not market multiples, trading targets or guidance.
Use date-aligned price, verified tangible book, peer comparable return and actual ECL capital effects before calculating expected returns. Do not add separate subsidiary value to a group-based multiple without removing double counting.
Key takeaways
Track Q3 actual global NIM against FY27 2.60–2.70% guidance; management credit cost below 0.4%; recovery progress versus 13,000 full-year target (H1 5,594), with scope consistent; actual ECL effect; RWA and CET1. Analyst review thresholds: global NIM below 2.45% for two quarters, fresh slippage ratio above 1%, NNPA above 0.40%, underlying funding gap above 7pp, CET1 below 13%. These are review signals, not regulatory limits. The thesis breaks if faster new lending raises loss rates while core earnings fail to replace legacy income. Preserve existing numerical scores and shared sector appendix.
Sources: October 16 Q2 investor presentation, ID 11861, detailed tables slides 9–12, 21–26, 27–30, 47; October 16 earnings call, ID 56321, opening and Q&A on core profit, IBPC, FCNR, ECL and underwriting; original exchange financial filing. Detailed P&L selected over inconsistent headline operating-profit growth; full independent statutory reconciliation, market price/peer valuation and actual ECL impact remain open. No target price.
---
Key takeaways
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/d48409a9-50c6-4b4f-a230-43f9b97afcf8.pdf
https://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachHis/ac32cf6e-c473-4125-a339-e18fab5ee8be.pdf
This is dated research, not a live market quote. Scenarios and historical performance are not guarantees.